With-operator versus without-operator: a critical scope boundary
When you supply yourself as an operator together with your own machine, the contract has two elements: your labour (within CIS under s.74(2) Finance Act 2004, as earth-moving, excavation and civil engineering operations are listed construction operations) and the plant element. The plant hire portion can be excluded from the deduction base because CIS deductions apply to labour only. If you operate on a dry-hire basis, providing only the machine without an operator, that is in essence a plant hire arrangement and falls outside CIS entirely under s.74(3). Getting the split documented correctly on your invoices protects against your contractor applying the 20% rate to the full contract value.